I hope I might be able to interest you in an idea I’ve had floating around my head for a while. Just as a once off, I’d like to recruit bloggers (and non-bloggers too) to read the papers over one weekend. Specifically, over next weekend.
Not one paper, or two, but as many as possible. Ideally, to read them all. (Though I’m not sure if anyone would have the time to read everything). And to read them with a critical eye- to note down when news reports don’t tally with what they know, or when columnist’s arguments don’t make sense. Or when they seem to be intent on talking about something that has nothing to do with you.
Above all, to try to articulate what, if anything, we’d like to see improved in the papers on our shelves by clearly identifying where they seem to have fallen down.
To try to inject a little fun into the exercise, I propose to set up shop in a city centre venue (that’s Dublin city centre, if you’re near another city) from 1pm with a huge pile of papers on Saturday and Sunday. Somewhere with chairs, drink and brunch-styles munches. Who knows, somebody might turn up and start blogging from the place there and then. I thought the Mezzanine in the Westin Hotel has pretty nice comfy sofas to sit and read at. Suggestions of alternative venues welcome.
Feel free to drop in, if you’re in town, or to read your own paper at home and contribute your thoughts from there. (If you’d like to, tag it paperround so they can all be found easily).
And, if you want, ask your friends to come along, bring partners and/or kids (of reading age or otherwise).
Its a kind of a meet-up, but also an experiment.
Speaking for myself, I think that the standard of newspapers has fallen in the past, say 5 years. And I think Ireland needs a strong, active and questioning press. And having been involved in, for example, court cases which I didn’t recognise when I read some of the reports, I’ve started to wonder if what I read is even factually accurate. I think that if a group of even semi-alert weekend readers start to examine what we’re given we might (perhaps) find that the authority of print starts to drain away quite quickly.
To try to get the widest spread of snapshots (Workday, Saturday and Sunday papers) I’ll also be buying all the daily papers on Friday. But, as I don’t have the day off work, I’m afraid there won’t be any lounging around then.
Let me know what you think.
12 Comments
[…] Check out the blog post for more, and give your support if you’re interested. […]
Great idea. Coincidentally, I wrote my first contribution to this effort two days ago over on Cedar Lounge: The brainiest journalists don’t come from The Sunday Times
Is this the sort of thing you had in mind?
Great idea. I think a distributed critical analysis of media output would be tremendously interesting to see. My own experience of seeing things that I have experienced reported in the media is that astonishing inaccuracies are not uncommon. If you could get enough people to participate in such an analysis, you could incorporate the views of first hand participants in a large proportion of the stories covered.
And that’s exactly the type of thing that the blogosphere could potentially do. Having said that, I’d guess that this weekend is a bit soon to generate enough interest to get that much momentum. Still it’s an interesting experiment and if I’m around town, I’ll drop in to say hello.
Count me in, unfortunately I wont be in the capital but I can do this from Dundalk if thats ok.
[…] Simon McGarr is not only one of the incisive minds at the crack legal team of McGarr Solicitors but something of an ideas man about the blogosphere. His freshest scheme involves an invitation to bloggers and non-bloggers alike to cast a critical eye over this weekend’s crop of newspapers at a marathon Read-In in the mezzanine of the Westin Hotel in Dublin City Centre. […]
[…] This is very noble and high-minded, and it bears almost no relation to what I read over the weekend as part of Paper Round. On Saturday, I read several newspapers cover to cover, and I can count on one hand the number of stories that were not fed directly to the journalist by a PR person, in whose obvious interest it was to see the story appear in print. I saw on the front page of a reputable national newspaper an advertisement only half-heartedly disguised as story. I saw, on the same front page, a headline which implied the exact opposite of what was later revealed in the story to have been the truth. […]
[…] has had an idea. You see Simon loves newspapers. He writes about them, speaks about them, and researches them, with the intensity others reserve for rock music or sports results. So when Simon tells me […]
[…] culture magazine Tuppenceworth, providing free legal advice to Digital Rights Ireland, he’s saving Irish Journalism from itself, and reinvigorating democracy. Lest this list seem insufficient praise for the man, let me just […]
[…] Round. tuppenceworth’s Paper Round seems to be the only easily accessible comparative analysis around at the […]
[…] has had an idea. You see Simon loves newspapers. He writes about them, speaks about them, and researches them, with the intensity others reserve for rock music or sports results. So when Simon tells me […]
[…] magazine Tuppenceworth, or providing free legal advice to Digital Rights Ireland, he’s saving Journalism from itself, and reinvigorating democracy. Lest this list seem insufficient praise for the man, let me just […]
[…] magazine Tuppenceworth, or providing free legal advice to Digital Rights Ireland, he’s saving Journalism from itself, and reinvigorating democracy. Lest this list seem insufficient praise for the man, let me just […]